Charges Dropped in Alleged Imam Attack on Downtown Subway Platform Updated December 17, 2010 11:32am

SEE MORE PHOTOS

By Julie Shapiro

DNAinfo Reporter/Producer

LOWER MANHATTAN — Most charges have been dropped against a pair of men accused of attacking an imam in a downtown subway station this month.

Albert Melendez, 30, from Harlem, and Eddie Crespo, 28, a Metropolitan Transportation Authority officer from Staten Island, were initially accused of making anti-Muslim remarks while assaulting a 49-year-old imam Dec. 8 on the uptown A platform at Canal Street, according to police.

The charges against a pair of men who allegedly attacked an imam in the Canal Street subway station have all been dropped or downgraded. (Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

Both men were charged with assault and robbery as hate crimes after they allegedly called the imam a "camel jockey," punched him in the face and threw his kufi, a religious head covering, on the subway tracks, prosecutors said.

But all charges were dropped against Crespo after a grand jury voted not to indict him this week, the Manhattan District Attorney’s office said. And the grand jury downgraded the felony charges against Melendez, indicting him only on a misdemeanor, the DA’s office said.

The misdemeanor charge will not be revealed until Melendez is arraigned in Supreme Court on Jan. 11, the DA’s office said. It is unclear whether he is still being charged with a hate crime.

While prosecutors initially described the confrontation as a bias-fueled attack initiated by Melendez, Angel Soto, Melendez’s lawyer, described it as a chance encounter gone awry.

At Melendez’s first court appearance earlier this month, Soto said Melendez was on his way home Dec. 8 when he made accidental contact with the imam. Melendez extended his hand to apologize, but the imam refused to touch it, Soto said.

As the argument escalated, Crespo stepped in to break it up, Soto said.

Soto said the hate-crime charges were "trumped-up."

Soto and Crespo’s lawyer did not immediately return calls for comment Friday.

The DA’s office declined to comment on the dropped and downgraded charges.

RELATED CONTENT

• Two Men Arrested in Alleged Bias Attack on Downtown Subway Platform Two men have been arraigned on hate charges after allegedly beating an Imam, calling him a "camel jockey" and throwing his religious head covering onto the subway tracks.  [DNAinfo]

By Julie Shapiro, DNAinfo.com

Follow Julie on Twitter @JulieShapiro