Rent Guidelines Board Illegally Raised Rents of 300,000 Tenants, Court Says

The decision determined that supplemental hikes in '08 and '09 were illegal, meaning $100M may be refunded.

Rent Guidelines Board to Propose Rent Increases to City's Rent-Stabilized HousingTenant advocates and elected officials gathered at City Hall last year to urge the Rent Guidelines Board to vote for a rent freeze. (Flickr/West Side Neighborhood Alliance)

By Patrick Hedlund

DNAinfo News Editor

MANHATTAN — More than a quarter-million rent-regulated tenants may receive refunds following a court ruling Tuesday that found the city illegally hiked rents for lower-income residents.

The court's decision upheld an earlier ruling that the Rent Guidelines Board illegally imposed supplemental rent increases in 2008 and 2009 for rent-stabilized tenants who lived in apartments for more than six years and paid less than $1,000 a month.

The supplemental increase forced those tenants to pay an additional $45 for one-year leases and $85 for two-year leases and was called a "poor tax" by its opponents.

The ruling means that up to 300,000 tenants who signed renewal leases could receive refunds totaling $100 million, the Daily News reported.

“The creation of this ‘poor tax’ was a direct attack by the Rent Guidelines Board on low-income tenants — the very New Yorkers hit hardest by the economic downturn,” said City Council Speaker Christine Quinn in a statement lauding the court decision.

The RGB will seek to appeal the ruling, which stated the board can’t institute a supplemental increase based on a tenant’s longevity, said RGB Executive Director Andrew McLaughlin.

The board will determine this year’s increases Thursday after voting last month for rent hikes of 2 to 4 percent for one-year leases and 4 to 6 percent for two-year leases.

Affordable housing advocates have been urging a rent freeze given the current economic situation and high unemployment rates.

Thursday's final vote will take place from 5:30 to 9:30 p.m. at the Cooper Union's Great Hall, 7 East 7th St., in the East Village.

Comments comment

Log in to comment.
View all comments
See next article
GET LOCAL NEWS FIRST
Download the free DNAinfo.com application, and get the latest local news in the palm of your hand. DOWNLOAD
INSTANT GRATIFICATION
Do you need to know the minute a story breaks? Subscribe to RSS feeds for instant gratification.SUBSCRIBE
ADVERTISEMENT

DNAinfo Weekly Quiz
Twitter @dnainfofacebook
Video Update
twitter@dnainfo
    Weather Update