Elderly Nun Killed After NYPD Car Chase in Harlem Ends in a Crash

Sister Celine Graham was struck and killed by two robbery suspects fleeing from police in Harlem.

Sister Celine Graham was on her way from the Handmaids of Mary Church to physical therapy with her aide, Patricia Cruz, when she was struck and killed by a car Tuesday morning, church members said. (DNAinfo/Jill Colvin)

By Jill Colvin and Olivia Scheck

DNAinfo Reporter/Producers

MANHATTAN — An 83-year-old nun crossing the street with her nurse's aide was struck and killed by two robbery suspects in a getaway car fleeing police on Lenox Avenue Tuesday morning, police and witnesses said.

Sister Mary Celine Graham and her aide, 58-year-old Patricia Cruz, were among six people injured when the fleeing blue Chrysler Pacifica collided with a silver Honda Odyssey and went into a tailspin at the corner of West 122nd Street.

Witnesses said the Pacifica was being chased by two police cruisers, an NYPD van and a police scooter in the moments before the 9:40 a.m. crash.

Sister Graham, who became a nun with the Franciscan Handmaids of Mary at age 22, spent her life taking care of preschool students including those at the St. Benedict’s Day Nursery in Harlem and the Camp St. Edward in Staten Island, a spokesman for the Archdiocese of New York said. She'd  recently begun suffering Parkinsons disease,

The scene at 122nd Street and Lenox Avenue after a deadly crash that killed one and injured at least four others. (DNAinfo/Jill Colvin)

She was declared dead on arrival at Harlem Hospital. Her bent cane was discovered lying on the ground next to her, a witness said.

"It was terrible — all you saw was bodies lying all over the place," a witness, Julie Wells, 58, said after the crash.

Police arrested William Robbins, 18 after the crash. He was not immediately charged. Police were still searching for two other suspects who escaped on Tuesday afternoon.

The drama began on Lenox Avenue, between 122nd Street and 123rd streets, earlier that morning when a 21-year-old Columbia University student called police from his cell phone to say that he'd been robbed at gunpoint by three men who took off in a blue car, according to police.

Minutes later, police spotted the car on Lenox Avenue, near 141st Street, a detective at the scene said. They pulled the car over and arrested the driver on the street.

NYPD Car Chase in Harlem Ends in a Crash, Six People InjuredThe scene of a car crash on Lenox Avenue Tuesday morning. (DNAinfo/Jill Colvin)

But before officers could detain the two men sitting in the back, one of the suspects jumped into the front seat and spun the car around with the third suspect still in the backseat, police said.

As the robbery suspects sped down Lenox Avenue toward the scene of the original robbery, they drove into the Honda Odyssey, which was turning right from West 122nd Street. A street sweeping vehicle was also in the middle of the intersection.

The driver of the Honda, a 55-year-old mom, had to be cut out of her car. The mom and her 15-year-old son were taken to St. Luke's Hospital, where they were listed in a stable condition.

Sr. Graham was remembered as a “selfless” nun whose entire life was devoted to others.

“She was a Franciscan Handmaid to her toes, in her selfless dedication to serving ‘her children’,” Sister Loretta Theresa Richards, the order’s superior, said in a statement. “She was always trying to make things better for somebody else.”

SLIDESHOW: Elderly Nun Killed After NYPD Car Chase in Harlem Ends in a Crash

Sr. Graham’s nursing aide, Patricia Cruz, of Brooklyn, was recovering at Harlem Hospital with bruised kidneys and internal bleeding, her family said.

Cruz asked her family “to pray for her,” and does not yet know that her companion of a decade was killed during the crash, because the family fears it would upset her too much, Cruz' relatives said.

Cruz' husband blamed police for setting off the chain of events that injured his wife.

"If they weren't chasing him, this wouldn't have happened," said Candelario Cruz, 58.

Another pedestrian injured in the crash, a 26-year old electrician named Steven Phan, was also recovering at Harlem Hospital. Phan's brother said he was stable and had a broken leg.

One pedestrian refused treatment at the scene.

Ava Arrington, 53, was home in her apartment on Lenox Avenue when she said she heard sirens. Less than five seconds later, she heard the crash.

"It was metal and glass crunching," she said.

Arrington looked out her window and saw the two smashed cars, along with two people motionless on the ground in the street. She also saw a black cane with a straight handle on the pavement beside them.

"Oh my goodness, it was horrific. I heard people screaming, 'Oh my God, Oh my God!'" she said. "It looked very, very bad. Nobody was moving."

"It's so sad."

Comments 3comments

Log in to comment.
It the HEIGHT of insanity to blame the police and NOT the criminal/robbers for this and similar tragedies. Such persons would rather see murderers and rapists run amok, than have the police stop them. This is one of the reasons criminals feel a sense of entitlement to commit their crimes; somehow, the cops are wrong for trying to stop or apprehend them. I could SOMEWHAT see the other side if the COPS had killed the nun.When the cops come after you, upon committing your CRIME, you're supposed to STOP and SURRENDER!
THINKINGMAN | August 9, 2010
Please go to departedngone and Let The World Know that we have lost a Good Life. Departed N Gone
warrk21 | June 23, 2010
Wait a minute,its a tragedy that this happened, she will not be forgotten there are not that many selfless people who devoted her life to helping others like she did. So many lives she has touched through out her time here on earth, she will not be forgotten! But to blame the crash on the police rather than the hoodlums that committed the crime seems a little odd. Maybe they shouldn't robbed someone at gunpoint to begin with, hell y did they even have a gun in the first place, their problems started long b4 the police started chasing them.
fenrir02 | June 23, 2010
ITS VERY SAD THAT AN ELDERLY WOMAN JUST DIED DUE TO A POLICE CHASE..IF COPS WOULD NOT HAVE CHASED THAT CAR,, THAT WOMAN WOULD HAVE BEEN ALIVE..NOW WHY..THE WORD THAT FIXES EVERYTHING...SORRY.......SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN ALIVE IF COPS WOULD NOT HAVE CHASED THIS CAR ON A BUSY STREET....MOST POLICE WANT TO BE HEROS..THEY MUST FIRST THINK OF THE SAFTY OF A PERSON ON A BUSY STREET,,NOW THIS POOR WOMAN IS DEAD..AND FOR GOTTEN...CHANGE THE LAW,,,,,,,,/ STOP COPS FROM TAKEING MATTERS IN THERE HANDS ON CHASEING A CAR ON BUSY STREETS...
HARLEMCITY | June 22, 2010
I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY!!!COPS CHASE BAD GUYS..IN BUSY STREETS..ALOT OF PEOPLE COULD HAVE GOTTEN KILLED DUE TO A POLICE CHASE..PLEASE MAKE A LAW THAT COPS CANNOT CHASE NO SPEEDING CARS AT ALL ON BUSY STREETS..HOW ABOUT DUE TO THIS CHASE ALL THOSE PEOPLE WOULD HAVE DIED.BECAUSE COPS STARTED CHASEING SOME BAD GUYS,,WHAT WOULD THE COPS SAY ;;;SORRY;;;SORRY DONT BRING BACK A LIFE OF A PERSON...SO PLEASE MAKE A LAW NOW ....BECAUSE IF COPS KEEP CHASEING CARS ON BUSY STREETS ONE DAY ALOT OF PEOPLE MIGHT GET KILLED,,FOR A CHASE,,A LIFE IS MORE INPORTANT THEN A CHASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
HARLEMCITY | June 22, 2010
View all comments
See next article
GET LOCAL NEWS FIRST
Download the free DNAinfo.com application, and get the latest local news in the palm of your hand. DOWNLOAD
INSTANT GRATIFICATION
Do you need to know the minute a story breaks? Subscribe to RSS feeds for instant gratification.SUBSCRIBE
ADVERTISEMENT

DNAinfo Weekly Quiz
Twitter @dnainfofacebook
Video Update
twitter@dnainfo
    Weather Update